Wild radishes and their offspring keep hungry caterpillars at bay using ‘on-demand’ anti-predator gene expression, Stanford researchers find
Wild radishes fend off caterpillars using “on-demand” anti-predator gene expression and these protections can extend to the next generation.
Lions, bears and other clawed creatures tend to top lists of nature’s most protective parents, but a new study has found that plants can also go to impressive lengths to protect their young.
In a new study, published Aug. 17 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Stanford researchers show that wild radish plants turn on different anti-predator genes during key phases of their lives in response to predation from caterpillars. Moreover, the plants can also pass these “on-demand” defensive strategies on to their offspring to prepare them for the predation they are likely to experience as seedlings and adults.
Scientists have known that parent plants can pass helpful defenses to their offspring, but how plants allocate these defenses over time and across generations is poorly understood. Understanding how plants protect themselves matters to humans for lots of reasons, explained senior author Rodolfo Dirzo, the Bing Professor of Environmental Science at the School of Humanities and Sciences.
For example, Aspirin, morphine and the heart medication digitalis are a few of the many drugs derived from chemical defenses created by plants. Plants’ natural defenses can also be exploited by humans to protect crops and for pest management.
“The history of humanity has been heavily influenced by the evolution of plant-insect interactions,” said Dirzo, who is also a senior fellow at the Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment.
The war of the radishes
Plants arm themselves with toxins, spines and other chemical and physical defenses to keep plant-eating animals, known as herbivores, at bay. But defenses can be costly for plants to produce, so they often spend their resources on anti-herbivore defenses only when it benefits them most.
In plants, the genes responsible for generating anti-predator defenses are often “turned on” via a chemical “switch” called DNA methylation. DNA methylation is an example of an epigenetic (“epi” meaning “on top of”) mechanism that modifies gene behavior without altering the underlying DNA sequence of the genes themselves.
When Mar Sobral joined Dirzo’s lab as a postdoctoral scholar in 2011 she began investigating how predation can affect heritable epigenetic changes.
In a study published March 2021 in Frontiers in Plant Science, the team showed that wild radishes were much more likely to produce flowers with pink or purple flowers if their parents were attacked by caterpillars.
“Apparently, the epigenetic changes linked to increased physical and chemical defenses can also induce changes in pigment production because they have related pathways,” explained Sobral, who is now a researcher at the Universidade de Santiago de Compostela in Spain and is the first author of both studies.
A chemical call to arms
In order to delve deeper into how plants evolve and pass defenses to their offspring in response to predation, Sobral, Dirzo and Isabelle Neylan, a former undergraduate in Dirzo’s lab, designed a multigenerational greenhouse experiment to explore interactions between wild radish plants and their top predator, the cabbage butterfly caterpillar.
In wild radishes, anti-predator defenses manifest as bristly leaf hairs and toxic mustard oil. The team wanted to know how wild radish plants allocate their physical and chemical defenses as seedlings and adults, and how heightened defenses during a particular life stage may be transmitted across generations.
The greenhouse experiment enabled the researchers to explore their questions in a controlled environment – only cabbage butterfly caterpillars were allowed to graze on the wild radish plants, and the plants were given ample light, water, nutrients and a constant temperature.
The researchers hypothesized that wild radish plants would turn on defenses in response to caterpillar attacks.
They also predicted the offspring of plants attacked by caterpillars would have more defenses and would be more likely to produce defenses when attacked by caterpillars.
Lastly, since seedlings are fragile and more likely to be lethally damaged in this life stage, the team predicted that the ability to induce defenses would be strongest in seedlings.
The researchers tested their predictions using 160 wild radish plants and scores of voracious caterpillars. The caterpillars were allowed to attack plants for two weeks during two key life stages – when seedlings had produced their first two leaves, and when adult plants bloomed. For comparison, a sample of control plants was kept free of caterpillar attack.
The researchers estimated the effectiveness of each plants’ physical defenses by counting the density of hairs on leaf samples. Their chemical defenses, in the form of mustard oil exuded from the leaves, were also collected and analyzed. Finally, the leaf tissue of both attacked and non-attacked plants were analyzed for signs of DNA methylation.
The study confirmed that DNA methylation is a chemical call to arms in wild radish plants and that attacks by hungry caterpillars trigger DNA methylation in parent plants and in their offspring.
The experiments on the offspring of attacked wild radish plants revealed wild radishes’ physical and chemical defenses were easily turned on by predation at the seedling stage. However, only chemical defenses – not physical defenses – were deployed by the adult plants in response to attack.
“There were several surprises,” said Sobral. “We didn’t expect that adult plants can be induced to produce defenses and can display the defenses they inherited from their ancestors. We assumed these processes were mainly happening at the seedling stage.”
Discovering that wild radish plants can turn on anti-predator defenses as seedlings and adults, but that adults can only use chemical defenses, was also a surprise; it was generally thought that only seedlings can turn on anti-predator defenses.
This study helps inform our understanding of the many, complex plant-insect interactions on Earth, the researchers say.
“About 50 percent of the species scientists have discovered and named on the planet are composed of ‘higher’ plants (such as ferns, conifers and flowering plants) and the insects that feed on them,” Dirzo said.
And those are just the species we know about, he pointed out. “Thus, their interactions represent a central feature of Earth’s biodiversity,” he added. “We cannot understand the diversity of life on Earth without understanding the interactions between plants and the organisms that feed on them.”
Isabelle Neylan is now a graduate student at the University of California-Davis. Additional co-authors on the study, titled “Phenotypic plasticity in plant defense across life stages: Inducibility, transgenerational induction, and transgenerational priming in wild radish,” include Luis Sampedro of the Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, Spain and David Siemens of Black Hills State University, South Dakota.
Funding for this research was provided by Stanford University.
To read all stories about Stanford science, subscribe to the biweekly Stanford Science Digest.