Science



March 19, 2010, 3:33 pm

Could Icelandic Whale Make Its Way Into Danish Pork?

March 20, 11:15 p.m. | Updated A couple of readers have noted a news release from the government of Iceland explaining that the records showing shipments of whale meal to Denmark were in error and the shipments were actually fishmeal. Here’s the relevant quote:

Regarding the alleged illegal exports of whale meal to Denmark, it has now been confirmed that the two shipments, 775 kilos of meal in January 2009 and 22,750 kilos of meal in March 2009, were fish meal, wrongly quoted in export declarations by the Icelandic exporter as whale meal. Statistics Iceland has confirmed that this will be corrected on their website, effective on 31 March 2010 when revised figures for 2009 will be published. Information regarding this matter will also be conveyed to the Danish Authorities.

March 19 | This is a query for contacts in Denmark or around the European Union who might know whether there’s any way to track how ground-up whale, called whale meal, ends up being used after it’s imported from Iceland.

The Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society has posted Icelandic government records showing sales of whale meat, oil and meal included about 26 tons of whale meal bound for Denmark in 2009. The shipments are part of a growing international trade in whale and whale products — Japan is by far the dominant buyer — that has prompted growing criticism from the conservation group and other whale campaigners.

“Iceland has apparently returned to the business of mincing whales to make meal, and seems to be testing out potential markets for their products,” said Chris Butler-Stroud of the Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society. “All governments must be vigilant and take the strongest possible steps to prevent this trade continuing.”

The group issued a news release laying out its concerns about the whale-meal trade, particularly whether this kind of product can be tracked so consumers of pork, fish or other products can be sure they’re not indirectly consuming whale:

In a 2009 interview with local news media, in a response to a question about the profitability of whaling, the owner of Iceland’s fin whaling company indicated that while whale meat is the most valuable product, processed whale products such as melted fat and pulverized whale bone could be turned into “meat meal and then mixed with other meal…” (link is in Icelandic).

W.D.C.S. is asking that if Iceland was successful in getting its whale meal into Denmark, how was the meal then used?

Traditionally whale meal was used to feed pigs and potentially now could also be used to feed fish in fish farms. But whilst Iceland says it exported this meal, did it arrive and if it did, what happened to it?

EC Feed Hygiene Regulation (EC 183/2005), which was meant to improve both feed safety and traceability, should ensure the ability of EC inspectors to determine whether Iceland’s whale meal entered the food chain in Denmark, although last week the U.K. Food Standards Agency issued a call for consultation on the need for clearer guidelines on record keeping requirements for feed use.

I have sent queries to Danish environmental officials and will update this post when there is a response. Here’s video shot last year of Iceland’s fleet hauling in some fin whales, the world’s second-biggest whale species:


Earth and Us on Twitter

  • Loading tweets...

About Dot Earth

Andrew C. Revkin on Climate Change

By 2050 or so, the world population is expected to reach nine billion, essentially adding two Chinas to the number of people alive today. Those billions will be seeking food, water and other resources on a planet where, scientists say, humans are already shaping climate and the web of life. In Dot Earth, reporter Andrew C. Revkin examines efforts to balance human affairs with the planet’s limits. Conceived in part with support from a John Simon Guggenheim Fellowship, Dot Earth tracks relevant news from suburbia to Siberia. The blog is an interactive exploration of trends and ideas with readers and experts. You can follow Mr. Revkin on Twitter and Facebook.

Introducing Apture Logo

Apture VideoApture allows readers to dig deeper into a subject without ever leaving the blog post. When you click on any link marked by the icons video icon, photo icon, or audio icon, you will be able to view video, reference materials, images and other related media. Please e-mail your feedback and thoughts on this feature to apture@nyt.com.

On the Dot

Energy
New Options Needed

wind powerAccess to cheap energy underpins modern societies. Finding enough to fuel industrialized economies and pull developing countries out of poverty without overheating the climate is a central challenge of the 21st century.

Climate
The Arctic in Transition

arctic meltEnshrined in history as an untouchable frontier, the Arctic is being transformed by significant warming, a rising thirst for oil and gas, and international tussles over shipping routes and seabed resources.

Society
Slow Drips, Hard Knocks

water troubles Human advancement can be aided by curbing everyday losses like the millions of avoidable deaths from indoor smoke and tainted water, and by increasing resilience in the face of predictable calamities like earthquakes and drought.

Biology
Life, Wild and Managed

wildlifeEarth’s veneer of millions of plant and animal species is a vital resource that will need careful tending as human populations and their demands for land, protein and fuels grow.

Slide Show

pollution
A Planet in Flux

Andrew C. Revkin began exploring the human impact on the environment nearly 30 years ago. An early stop was Papeete, Tahiti. This narrated slide show describes his extensive travels.

Video

revking at the north pole
Dot Earth on YouTube

Many of the videos featured here can be found on Andrew Revkin’s channel on YouTube. Recent reader favorites:

Blogroll

News
Earth and Environmental Science and Engineering
Poverty, Development, and Design
Media and Environment
Environment and Sustainability Voices
Analysis and Policy
FREE-MARKET ADVOCATES, “SKEPTICS,” INDUSTRY VIEWS
YOUTH

Archive

Recent Posts

March 22

New Light Shed on North Pole Ice Trends

As the sun rises for the long North Pole summer, new research points to a big role for winds in shaping ice patterns there.

March 21

From Wishful Thinking to Real-World Action on Climate

Moving from wishful thinking on warming to real-world actions that might blunt risk.

March 19

Could Icelandic Whale Make Its Way Into Danish Pork?

Exports of ground whale parts from Iceland to Denmark stir concerns.

March 18

A Turkish Builder on Istanbul’s Deadly Buildings

A Turkish builder argues for rebuilding a megacity facing an inevitable disaster.

March 17

Your Dot: Climate Concerns

Readers weigh in on arguments for human-driven warming and the hurdles to addressing the issue.

News From Green Inc.

Energy, the Environment and the Bottom Line

Green IncHow will the pressures of climate change, limited fossil fuel resources and the mainstreaming of “green” consciousness reshape society? Follow the money. Our energy and environment reporters will track the high-stakes pursuit of a greener globe. Join the discussion at Green Inc.

Subscribe