Opinion



March 8, 2010, 10:15 pm

Do You Miss Him Yet?

A billboard along I-35 in Minnesota.Associated Press A billboard along I-35 in Minnesota.

I know you’re not supposed to, but I just love to say I told you so.

What I told you back on Sept. 28, 2008, was that within a year of the day he left office George W. Bush would come to be regarded with affection and a little nostalgia. The responses (over 300 before the comments were closed) to that prediction were overwhelmingly negative; even the very few who agreed with me attributed what they took to be a sad fact to the stupidity of the American people. The other 290 or so said things like “No way”; “Are you kidding?”; ”Are you mad?”;“What a ridiculous and insulting premise!”; “I’ll miss him like a rash”; “This must be a satire”; “Bush is a sociopath”; “George Bush has destroyed this country”; “History won’t forgive him”; and (a popular favorite) “I hate the man.”

Well it’s a bit more than a year now and signs of Bush’s rehabilitation are beginning to pop up. One is literally a sign, a billboard that appeared recently on I-35 in Minnesota. Occupying the right side (from the viewer’s viewpoint) is a picture of Bush smiling genially and waving his hand in a friendly gesture. Occupying the left side is a simple and direct question: “Miss me yet?” The image is all over the Internet, hundreds of millions of hits, and unscientific Web-based polls indicate that more do miss him than don’t.

A perhaps more substantial sign incorporates a sign famous (or infamous) in the Bush presidency. The March 8 cover of Newsweek reproduces the famous 2003 photograph of Bush on the flight deck of the U.S.S. Lincoln. The president is in the left of the picture, striding away from the famous banner proclaiming “Mission Accomplished.”

Those words haunted Bush for the next five years, but now, Newsweek reports, they may play differently because — and this is emblazoned on the cover — we may have “Victory At Last.” It has to be said, declare the cover-story’s writers, that “now almost seven hellish years later . . . something that looks mighty like democracy is emerging in Iraq”; and, they add (eerily echoing Bush’s words in 2003), this development “most certainly is a watershed event that could come to represent a whole new era in the history of the massively undemocratic Middle East.”

Of course, one might disagree with that assessment, but the fact that it is made in the lead article of a major mainstream magazine tells its own story. It is a story that intersects with another, the story of the precipitous decline in Barack Obama’s support and of a growing suspicion, found on the left as well as on the right, where it is much more than a suspicion, that the politics of change may have been a slogan with less promise in its future than “Mission Accomplished.” (The imminent passage of a health care bill keeps being predicted, but so far no “victory at last.”)

Analyses of how this has happened are plentiful and varied, but most agree that it had something to do with the summer of 2009, when the town meetings that seemed a good, nicely democratic idea in the spring turned into a recruiting device for the angry crowds that would become the Tea Party.

At the same time, Bush profited from the fact that he kept a low profile and didn’t snipe at his successor, a task left to his vice president, who therefore took upon himself the enmity and scorn previously directed at his former boss. Dick Cheney was, in effect, a lightning rod, and he was joined in that function by Sarah Palin, who slid neatly into the slot Bush had occupied in the mind of all good liberals for eight long years. Hatred and contempt of Palin is now the favorite pastime of those who have abandoned the cowboy from Texas and transferred their obsessive animus to the belle of Alaska (who, I say again, is more formidable than many in both parties believe.)

Meanwhile, Bush’s policies came to seem less obviously reprehensible as the Obama administration drifted into embracing watered-down versions of many of them. Guantanamo hasn’t been closed. No Child Left Behind is being revised and perhaps improved, but not repealed. The banks are still engaging in their bad practices. Partisanship is worse than ever. Obama seems about to back away from the decision to try 9/11 defendants in civilian courts, a prospect that led the ACLU to run an ad in Sunday’s Times with the subheading “Change or more of the same?” Above that question is a series of photographs that shows Obama morphing into guess who — yes, that’s right, George W. Bush.

And now, right on schedule, Bush has resurfaced (just as I imagined him doing a year ago last September ) to join Bill Clinton in a humanitarian relief effort. He is officially a member in good standing of the ex-presidents club, and the longer he lives the more his reputation will be burnished. To be sure, his post-presidency resume is still thin, but we can expect it to be beefed up by good deeds, ceremonial appearances and the activities that will surround the building and opening of his library at Southern Methodist University. We’ll see Bush the tour guide and Bush the patron of historical scholarship and, perhaps, even Bush the seminar leader.

And the judgment of history? Well, I’m not that foolish, but I will venture to say that it will be more nuanced than anything the professional Bush-haters — indistinguishable in temperament from the professional Obama-haters — are now able to imagine. He will not go to the top of the list, but neither will he be the figure of fun and derision he seemed destined to be only a year ago. You heard it here.


Stanley Fish is a professor of law at Florida International University, in Miami, and dean emeritus of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at the University of Illinois at Chicago. His column appears here on Tuesdays. He has also taught at the University of California at Berkeley, Johns Hopkins and Duke University. He is the author of 11 books, most recently “Save the World On Your Own Time,” on higher education. “The Fugitive in Flight,” a study of the 1960s TV drama, will be published in 2010.

Inside Opinionator

March 18, 2010
Lehman’s Demise, Dissected

If simple incentives had been in place on Wall Street, could the latest crisis have been largely avoided?

March 4, 2010
A Wall Street Witch Hunt

In 1987, Goldman Sachs made headlines for an insider trading arrest case marked by prosecutorial excess.

February 18, 2010
The Great Goldman Sachs Fire Sale of 2008

If everything was really under control after Lehman collapsed, why were Goldman executives dumping their stock by the bushelfull?

More From William D. Cohan »

March 17, 2010
The Purists

With purists at both ends of the political spectrum making it hard to govern, Dennis Kucinich’s reversal on health-care legislation seems brave, if overdue.

March 3, 2010
L.A. Consequential

Los Angeles is safer than it’s been in decades, having so far avoided the dire future many had predicted in the ’90s.

February 24, 2010
The Missionary Impulse

Zealous amateurs have damaged the efforts of more legitimate adoption services and relief agencies in Haiti.

More From Timothy Egan »

March 17, 2010
Is Passing the Health Care Bill Really a Bad Idea?

Gail Collins tries to talk David Brooks off the ledge.

March 12, 2010
Is the U.S. Following in Rome’s Footsteps?

Americans are in a bad mood. Is there a bright side?

March 5, 2010
In What Can We Trust?

Searching for reasons to be pessimistic these days is pretty easy.

More From The Conversation »

March 16, 2010
Christian Soldiers

The strategy that underlies many missionaries’ reverence for Allah.

March 9, 2010
Toyotas Are Safe (Enough)

A closer look at the statistics on death from sudden acceleration reveals why there’s little need to fear driving a Toyota.

February 23, 2010
The First Tea-Party Terrorist?

The man who crashed a small plane into an Austin I.R.S. office hoped to inspire an overreaction.

More From Robert Wright »

March 16, 2010
Divide and Diminish

The human impulse to parcel nature into smaller and smaller plots is a danger to biodiversity.

March 9, 2010
Breezy Love, or the Sacking of the Bees

The wind-pollination of flowers is a fascinating process, though perhaps less so if you suffer from allergies.

March 2, 2010
Evolution by the Grassroots

March’s Life-form of the Month is wildly successful, hugely influential and pretty much everywhere: grass.

More From Olivia Judson »

March 15, 2010
Pragmatism’s Gift

Is pragmatism just an academic philosophy, or can it help us live improved lives?

March 8, 2010
Do You Miss Him Yet?

As predicted, signs of nostalgia for George W. Bush.

March 1, 2010
Little Big Men

Many larger-than-life tough guys of the screen, it seems, just don’t measure up.

More From Stanley Fish »

March 11, 2010
Clarence Thomas, Silent but Sure

Justice Clarence Thomas has been silent on the bench, but his opinion that the Eighth Amendment doesn’t protect prisoners from harsh treatment is clear in his writing.

February 25, 2010
Missing the Tea Party

The Supreme Court’s campaign finance ruling has both angered conservatives and given the Obama administration an opportunity.

February 11, 2010
Saved by the Swiss

With some last-minute maneuvering, the Obama administration looks as if it will avoid a test of the limits of executive power at the Supreme Court.

More From Linda Greenhouse »

February 5, 2010
Oh, What a Lovely Mess!

NBC’s recent adventures in talk-show-host management remind one former talk-show host of his own adventures in prime time with another network.

January 22, 2010
Awesome, and Then Some

An on-set encounter with John Wayne revealed an unexpected side of the actor.

January 8, 2010
Why, I Oughta . . . and I Did

It took a local television host to bring a (professionally) even-tempered first-time author to the boiling point.

More From Dick Cavett »

All-Nighters
At Midnight, All the Doctors…
March 18, 2010
Home Fires
A Small Victory in Afghanistan
March 17, 2010
All-Nighters
Night Lights, Blankets and Lullabies
March 14, 2010
Steven Strogatz
Square Dancing
March 14, 2010
The Thread
Judging Obama’s ‘Pep Rally’
March 12, 2010

All Contributors »

Opinionator Highlights

A Small Victory in Afghanistan

As life slowly returns to a once devastated town in Afghanistan, a Marine who fought there takes solace.

Night Lights, Blankets and Lullabies

How children, and their parents, cope with the nightly passage into sleep.

In the Night Kitchen

Baking from memory in the wee hours of the morning.

Thumbnail
The A-to-Z Cure

Instead of counting sheep, listing ailments.

Home Fires: Narrative and Memory at War

All war tales, even “The Iliad,” must bend the truth to serve the needs of a well-crafted story.