Health



March 12, 2010, 3:20 pm

Nelson’s Support May Depend on Student Loan Changes

Of all the grief Democrats have taken in the health care debate, perhaps no aspect of it caused greater heartburn than the extra Medicaid money for Nebraska that Senate Democratic leaders inserted into the Senate bill in hopes of locking in the support of Senator Ben Nelson, Democrat of Nebraska.

Mr. Nelson has long since disavowed the provision, which Republicans continue to deride as the “Cornhusker kickback.” Democrats plan to remove it from the final health care legislation.

Senator Ben Nelson on Capitol Hill on Wednesday.Harry Hamburg/Associated Press Senator Ben Nelson on Capitol Hill on Wednesday.

But now that Democrats are planning to include an overhaul of student loan programs in the expedited budget package along with the final health care legislation, they may end up losing Mr. Nelson’s support anyway.

Mr. Nelson is a strong ally of Nelnet, a private student lending company based in Nebraska. Nelnet is one of several private banks whose lending practices have been questioned by federal and state officials.

In 2007, the Bush administration determined that Nelnet improperly collected $278 million in federal subsidies, but the company was allowed to keep the money.

Jake Thompson, a spokesman for Mr. Nelson, said that the senator would wait to see final legislative language before deciding how to vote, but that Mr. Nelson was reluctant to support any legislation that ended the role of private banks in federal student loan programs.

“He’s said he’d have a hard time supporting a bill brought forward using reconciliation that eliminates private student lending,” Mr. Thompson said. “But he’d have to see the actual language to determine how he’d vote.”

President Obama has proposed an overhaul to the student loan program that would stop payments to private banks and save billions of dollars that would be redirected to Pell grants for low-income students. The private lenders now get paid by the government to make risk-free loans using taxpayer money. The banks have lobbied fiercely to keep a grip on some profits from federal student loan programs.

Mr. Nelson, who is generally known as a fiscal conservative, is particularly concerned that jobs could be lost in his home state. Officials say the student loan overhaul, by switching all schools over to loans made directly by the federal government, would save the taxpayers as much as $67 billion over 10 years.


Recent Posts

March 12

The Last-Minute Ad Campaigns

Both sides in the health care debate have taken to the airwaves with new commercials intended to influence the outcome.

March 12

Nelson’s Support May Depend on Student Loan Changes

Democrats may lose Senator Ben Nelson's support for a health care overhaul over proposed changes to the student loan program, which are to be included in the final legislation.

March 12

C.B.O. Raises Cost Estimate for Senate Health Care Bill

The Congressional Budget Office revisited the Senate health care bill and found the final version slightly more expensive than before. Next up: the reconciliation package.

March 12

Pelosi Hopeful for House Vote by March 21

The House speaker, Nancy Pelosi, said on Friday that she hoped the House would vote on far-reaching health care legislation by March 21 and that President Obama would be in Washington see it happen.

March 11

A New Face in the Health Care Debate

Democrats rally around an 11-year-old from Seattle whose mother died after losing her job and health insurance.

Where Things Stand Now

CheckpointCheck this space for the latest updates from Washington and beyond.

White House | Democrats and Republicans aired their differences over proposed health care legislation at a bipartisan health care summit hosted by President Obama on Feb. 25. In light of Republican opposition, Democrats weighing budget reconciliation.

Senate | Republican Scott Brown won Kennedy's Senate seat on Jan. 19. Passed health care legislation, 60 to 39, on Dec. 24.

House | Votedto repeal insurers' antitrust exemption on Feb. 24. Passed health care legislation, 220 to 215, on Nov. 7.

Graphics: Health Reform History | Comparing the Plans

Full Text of the Bills: House Bill | Senate Bill | Senate Manager's Amendment | White House Proposal

The Times: The Health Care Debate

Democrats Struggle to Finish Health Bill
By ROBERT PEAR

Rank-and-file House Democrats were frustrated, saying they had received few details about what would be in the legislation.

Deal Gives New Life to Overhaul of Student Loans
By DAVID M. HERSZENHORN and TAMAR LEWIN

The deal would bundle a bill on student loan overhaul into an expedited budget package along with the Democratic health care legislation.

Learning to Keep Patients Safe in a Culture of Fear
By PAULINE W. CHEN, M.D.

The threat of blame, even malpractice, looms over doctors working to prevent medical errors.

Obama Gets Tough on Health Care Fraud
By HELENE COOPER and ROBERT PEAR

The president said he would unleash auditors in a crackdown on Medicare and Medicaid waste and fraud, a move to please both liberals and conservatives.

Virginia: Opting to Refuse Health Overhaul
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

The state legislature approved a measure that bucks any effort by President Obama and Congress to carry out a national health care overhaul in individual states.

Featured Posts

The Legislation
The Public Option
The Public Option

The public may have more appetite for the public option than many in Congress do.

Co-ops and Exchanges
Explaining the Exchange
vitamins

Understanding the principle, and the politics, of the “insurance exchange.”

Health Care Abroad
Taiwan

Taiwan implemented a Canadian-style single-payer system in less than a year.

Paying for Care
Insured, but Bankrupted Anyway

Medical bills are a major cause of personal bankruptcies in the United States, and proposed legislation isn’t likely to change that.

Times Topics
Tracking the Overhaul

The latest news, developments, resources and multimedia on efforts to revamp the health care system.

Glossary
Yes, I Speak Health Care

Capitation? Mandate? Here’s a handy guide to the terms popping up in the debate.



On the Blogs

Sebelius to Insurers: It's Not Too Late to Work Together

The administration's top health official tries to persuade insurance companies to get on board with the pending legislation.

Hoyer Dismisses Massa's Claims as 'Untrue'

The House majority leader joined of chorus of Democratic officials dismissing accusations that they orchestrated the ouster of an upstate congressman.

Massa Exits, but Also Blames Health Care Stance

The latest from the New York congressman who decided to leave office amid an ethics inquiry.

House Republican Postpones Resignation to Vote Against Health Care Bill

A Georgia Republican said he was persuaded to stay until the House votes on the Democrats' health care legislation.

The Latest Health Care Developments

It's a busy day for health care news.

Can Obama Bypass Republicans on Health?

The political risks of pushing through health care legislation without the G.O.P.

Did Obama Move Health Care Forward?

Will the president's words affect the political stalemate?

The G.O.P.'s Next Move on Health Care

What should the Republicans do now that they have the ability to change the game?

Medicare for 50-Somethings?

A Democratic plan to cover people 55 to 64 -- a group hard hit by layoffs.

Squeezing Money Out of Home Health Care

Does cutting Medicare spending on home health aides make good financial sense?

To Control Health Care Costs, Trace the Spending

The government can keep track of waste in the American health care system by keeping better track on how doctors choose to treat their patients, an economist writes.

From Arms to Entitlements

Health and Social Security spending went up. Military spending went down. Only one of those two trends will continue.

Health Care Reform and the 'Doc Fix'

For health-care reform to cut the deficit, it doesn't need to undo the "doc fix" -- the continued easing of Congressional curbs on Medicare payments to doctors. It just needs to improve upon the status quo.

Reader Response: Fraud and Abuse in U.S. Health Care

An economist responds to readers' comments and questions about his post on how frequently medical service providers try to defraud the government.

How Much Fraud and Abuse Is There in U.S. Health Care?

There's unlikely to be much in hospital systems, an economist writes. But the extraordinary administrative burden created to weed it out helps drive up the cost of care.

What Obama's New Health Care Plan Means for Small Businesses

What's unclear at the moment is whether this proposal reflects the views of Democratic leaders in Congress - that is, whether this is a bill the White House hopes can pass, or thinks can pass.

Your Business and Health Insurance Costs

How much have your business's health insurance rates gone up?

Entrepreneurs, Carefully Chosen, React to Obama's Speech

Even those who sat next to Michelle Obama have some questions.

Modernizing Government: An Entrepreneurial Perspective

President Obama calls business owners for tech support.

On Health Care, Readers Speak; The Agenda Responds

Please keep those cards and letters coming.

Home for Thanksgiving, and Managing Meds

A new brochure helps family members home for holiday visits talk to their parents about their multiple medications.

Easing Tensions in the Nursing Home

Conflicts between family members and nursing home staff may be familiar, but they are not inevitable, researchers say.

The Nursing Home as Battle Zone

Are conflicts with nursing home staff inevitable?

In Health Debate, the Oldest Voices Are Also the Faintest

The elderly are concerned about proposed changes to the health care system. But what of those patients who are most exposed to it?

When the Hospital Says 'So Long'

Tips on handling hospital discharges.

Multimedia

Comparing the House and the Senate Health Care Proposals
health-care reform

A look at how the proposals compare on some key issues.

A History of Health Care Reform
health care reform

For almost a century, presidents and members of Congress have tried and failed to provide universal health benefits to Americans.

Impact of Health Care Measures
health-table-graphic

New new health care measures will affect certain types of households.

Uncovered: Coping With, and Without, Insurance
health care

Covered by an inadequate plan, denied insurance or voluntarily without insurance – six men and women share their experiences.

Health Care Navigator

A list of topical resources selected by researchers and editors of The New York Times.

Draft Legislation
General Information
Advocacy Groups
Blogs
Video
Other Coverage

Subscribe