Advanced Search    Search VDARE's Blog

  VDARE.com Blog: [CIS Defends Itself From $PLC, Triangulates], etc.

TODAY'S LETTER: A NC Reader Urges Everyone To Check Their State’s Sex Offender Registry

03/18/10 - The Deem-o-crats' Towering Deception, by Michelle Malkin

03/17/10 - Will Sunday’s Amnesty March Backfire? by Donald A. Collins

03/17/10 - American Naïfs Bringing Ruin to Other Lands, by Paul Craig Roberts

03/17/10 - The Offshored Economy, by Paul Craig Roberts

03/16/10 - “Reap The Whirlwind”? What Our Rulers’ Non-Reaction To AR 2010’s Suppression Means, by Jared Taylor

Buy anything after entering Amazon through VDARE.COM and we get a commission, at no cost to you!

Steve Sailer's America's Half Blood Prince: Barack Obama's "Story of Race and Inheritance" now available in paperback - Also as PDF download. [Downloads since October 29 2008: 6475] click here!

Free PDF download of Alien Nation: Common Sense About America's Immigration Disaster Now Available! [Downloads since June 1 2007: 11315]

Sign up for (austerely infrequent) email bulletins - [archived here]

VDARE.COM SHOP!

Special VDARE.COM anthology issue of The Social Contract Magazine!

Peter Brimelow at the Miller Center of Public Affairs in RealVideo: Is Immigration a Problem? Are the Minute Men the Answer? [Text version] [Text version of Q&A]

Support VDARE.com with a tax-deductible contribution.
  accepted.
 
Announcing Unity Review—A 2004 VDARE.COM Anthology...

************

03/16/10 - The Slaughter on the Southern Border, by Michelle Malkin

03/16/10 - John McCain's Attack On Liberty, by Chuck Baldwin

03/15/10 - What Was Karl Rove Thinking? Some Clues From His Autobiography, by Steve Sailer

03/15/10 - Israel Sandbags Its U.S. Poodle, by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/14/10 - It Happened There (3): Court Cripples British National Party For Being Too, Well, British, by Sean Gabb

03/13/10 - Saturday Forum: A New York Reader Recalls His High School Days With Soledad O’Brien; etc.

03/12/10 - Obamacare + Amnesty = One-Term President. But Where’s The Immigration Moratorium? by Joe Guzzardi

03/12/10 - View From Lodi, CA Pittsburgh, PA: The Maligned Meatball—Make It Right For St. Joseph’s Day! by Joe Guzzardi

03/11/10 - The Fulford File: Why Did Obama Administration Drop Immigration Charges Against Agriprocessors’ Rubashkin?, by James Fulford

03/11/10 - Eric Massa And House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's Deficient Cleaning Service, by Michelle Malkin

03/11/10 - Free Trade’s Disemboweling Of America, by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/10/10 - Hispanic Sex Offenders Listed As White In Wisconsin. Why?, by Simon Krejsa

Editorial Collective

VDARE is a coalition. Some of us have distinguished oeuvres; some have deviant views (categories not necessarily exclusive). The satellite pages (click on name) represent our individual archives.

Thomas Allen
Bryanna Bevens
John Brimelow
Peter Brimelow
Randall Burns
Patrick Cleburne
Joseph E. Fallon
James Fulford
Joe Guzzardi
Athena Kerry
D. A. King
Juan Mann
Paul Craig Roberts
Steve Sailer
Rob Sanchez
Howard Sutherland
Brenda Walker
Allan Wall
John Wall
Chilton Williamson Jr.

(See also authors archive)

************

Free PDF download now available!

Alien Nation Round 2 - Afterword to the Paperback Edition

************

Peter Brimelow comments on his Teacher Union book and makes an offer to VDARE.COM readers...

************

Craig Nelsen vs. Bush on Immigration (video)

************

Libertarians and Immigration Archive

************

RECENT ARTICLES

03/09/10 - An Immigration Reformer, CPAC Sponsor, Reflects On Its Suppression Of Immigration, by Vincent Chiarello

03/09/10 - Desperate Dems Cling to Human Kiddie Shield, by Michelle Malkin

03/08/10 - Thoughts On America’s Jewish Ruling Class And Noblesse Oblige, by Steve Sailer

03/08/10 - Should Middle-Class Americans Subsidize $100,000-A-Year Pensions For Government Workers? by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/07/10 - It’s Happening There (2): “Free” Germany’s Police State, by Paul Gottfried

03/06/10 - Saturday Forum: A Former ACU Intern Confirms Its Anti-Amnesty Fund-Raising Scam; etc.

03/06/10 - View From Lodi, CA Pittsburgh, PA: Oscars And History, by Joe Guzzardi

03/05/10 - National Data: What Job Rebound? Immigrants Displace Americans at Record Clip, by Edwin S. Rubenstein

03/05/10 - Immigration Help Is On The Way To New York State—Maybe, by Joe Guzzardi

03/04/10 - Come Back, Stonewall Jackson! Hispanic Gangs Invade Shenandoah Valley, by A.W. Morgan

03/04/10 - Jim Bunning Was Pitching for America, by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/04/10 - The Obama Way: Bluster, Bully, Bribe, by Michelle Malkin

03/03/10 - Diversity Is Strength! It’s Also…The Incredible UCSD Hate Crime Hoax, by Ellison Lodge

03/03/10 - Thanks, Harry Reid! Can We Agree Trent Lott Was Right Now? by Charles G. Mills

03/02/10 - Rosa Pedalino Porter's American Story: Her Life In Three Languages, But Only One Country, by Athena Kerry

03/02/10 - Union Boss Andy Stern and Barack Obama: Fiscal Responsibility Fraudsters, by Michelle Malkin

03/02/10 - Hooray For Starbucks And Gun Rights, by Chuck Baldwin

03/02/10 - Is The Recovery Real? by Paul Craig Roberts

03/01/10 - Yeah, Yeah, “Attrition Through Enforcement”—But It’s No Substitute For An Immigration Moratorium, by Washington Watcher

03/01/10 - Global Warming—Hoax Of The 21st Century, by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/01/10 - Muslims Are Their Own Worst Enemy, by Paul Craig Roberts

02/28/10 - Samuel Eliot Morison And America’s Displaced Protestant Establishment, by Steve Sailer

02/27/10 - Saturday Forum: A Hungarian Immigrant Is Shocked By “Un-American” Los Angeles, Suggests We Emulate Singapore; etc.

02/26/10 - Memo From Middle America (Formerly Known As Memo From Mexico): Evangelicals, The NAE And Immigration, by Allan Wall

02/26/10 - Obama's Problems—and Ours, by Patrick J. Buchanan

02/26/10 - Is America Becoming A Police State? by Chuck Baldwin

02/25/10 - Keith Olbermann vs. Dallas Tea Partiers: Both Wrong, One American, by Ellison Lodge

02/25/10 - Oba-Kabuki: A Box-Office Bomb, by Michelle Malkin

02/25/10 - The Road to Armageddon, by Paul Craig Roberts

02/24/10 - National Data: Ron Unz Vanishes Hispanic Criminality…Not!, by Edwin S. Rubenstein

02/23/10 - Epic Beard Man, The MSM, And Citizen Reportage, by Alexander Hart

02/23/10 - Remembering The Alamo, by Chuck Baldwin

02/23/10 - Corruptocrat Eric Holder's National Security Cover-Up, by Michelle Malkin

02/22/10 - Diversity Is Strength! It’s Also…Ukraine’s Troubled Election, by Eugene Girin

02/22/10 - 2010 AR Conference Held Against All Odds, by Jared Taylor

02/22/10 - Liquidating The Empire, by Patrick J. Buchanan

02/22/10 - America’s First Suicide Bomber, by Paul Craig Roberts

02/21/10 - Without An Immigration Moratorium, How Long Can The GOP Hold Texas? by Steve Sailer

02/20/10 - Saturday Forum: A CA Reader Recalls When An Immigrant Ice Cream Vendor Was A Central Figure In A Terrorism Investigation; etc.

Prior 2010 Articles...

03/18/10 - Ethnonationalism: The Wars of Tribe and Faith Return, by Patrick J. Buchanan

03/17/10 - Saving the Tea Parties from Tom Tancredo…Or From Dick Armey? by Washington Watcher

TV’s Immigration News Blackout: How I Came To Miss Lou Dobbs' Show (But Not Him)

By Brenda Walker

Immigration reporting has largely disappeared from television, except for occasional updates on the impending amnesty attempt, since Lou Dobbs Tonight abruptly departed from the CNN network on November 11 with a dramatic speech by its eponymous host.

The lesson that Big Media seems to have gotten from the noisy Dobbs take-down by a coalition of far-left and Raza types: even factual reporting about immigration anarchy is no longer safe.

For all its faults, Lou Dobbs Tonight (aka LDT) had normalized immigration as a subject to be investigated like any other. But Dobbs' ego (or ambition) played into the hands of his critics.

The Open Borders squawk squad had complained furiously about Dobbs, and management demanded he cool it on "commentary". But, in addition, for several months prior to his swan song, straight news reporting on immigration disappeared entirely from Lou Dobbs Tonight.

If Dobbs had toned down his commentary and let the top-notch reporting of his staff stand alone, would that have satisfied CNN management? There's no way to know. But his post-resignation valentine to illegal aliens has been a climb-down of epic proportions. Maybe he could have saved his reporters had he done it earlier.

Dobbs’ groveling was epitomized by an interview with the Spanish-language network Telemundo in which he recommended legalization for some unspecified number of lawbreaking aliens. [Watch (Hint: he apologizes for not speaking Spanish in his first sentence.)]

The Wall Street Journal hit the major points of how the worm turned on November 12, 2009:

" ‘Whatever you have thought of me in the past, I can tell you right now that I am one of your greatest friends and I mean for us to work together,’ he said in a live interview with Telemundo's Maria Celeste. ‘I hope that will begin with Maria and me and Telemundo and other media organizations and others in this national debate that we should turn into a solution rather than a continuing debate and factional contest.’

“Mr. Dobbs twice mentioned a possible legalization plan for the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the U.S., saying at one point that ‘we need the ability to legalize illegal immigrants under certain conditions.’ “[Dobbs Reaches Out to Latinos, With Politics in Mind, By Peter Wallsten]

Then the late January panderfest with Bill O'Reilly demonstrated that Telemundo was not just an emotional episode. Dobbs recommended a "compromise, centrist piece of legislation that will meet the demands of most of the people who are in this country illegally."

How generous of him. If only La Raza had known!

More recently, Dobbs announced during a radio broadcast (Feb 2; Part 1 and Part 2) that he was bringing together a diverse group to discuss the immigration issue—from restrictionists to open-borders enthusiasts—with the underlying principle being “Compromise”. He went to far as to blame the American people for not demanding border security. Thinking like a politician apparently leads to bizarre twists.

It can get messy when media celebs think they can parlay their fame into a Senate seat or beyond, as Dobbs is rumored to believe. They often believe that cleverness on television or in the movies makes them brilliant public policy analysts who can solve the country's thorny problems. But star quality is not quite the same thing as having political chops. For example, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger's job performance recently rated a pathetic 27 percent approval, despite his portraying Conan the Barbarian and The Terminator in films. Senator Al Franken, a former Saturday Night Live comedian, earned a so-so 50 percent okay from his constituents. Perhaps he was too funny in a suit.

Peter Brimelow suspects that Dobbs has hired a conventional Beltway-type political consultant who has advised him to move to the mushy middle of the brave new borderless world. It sure looks that way, although the strategy is a sure loser. Dobbs has alienated his pro-sovereignty supporters and no Mexican will ever trust him anyway.

He might better have hired a behavioral psychologist who could have told him that when you reward an action, you get more of it—which is why an enforcement-only policy is the one true path to end immigration anarchy.

Dobbs' call for "compromise" is completely ahistorical. It ignores the long series of pardons, beginning with the 1986 Reagan Amnesty. Reversing decades of permissiveness requires tough measures. Millions of illegals must be encouraged home via attrition (removal of the jobs and benefits magnets) and outright repatriation.

The Dobbs drama has been a long strange trip, propelled along by the personality of the man with his ambitions and curious misunderstanding of immigration. But however the unusual saga came to be, the American public is the big loser. We now have less information about the most pressing issues threatening our values and future. We don't know what we don't know. And the dinosaur media can't be trusted to tell us.

Immigration is a big subject, far more complex than the mere legal/illegal dichotomy. Television viewers now see merely the occasional immigration stories that are easy to explain and non-controversial—Mexico narco-violence, border corruption and such. And there is not even much of that, although the amnesty flurry has created a minor uptick.

Lou Dobbs Tonight news reporters also explored important sub-topics including the usefulness of 287(g) for crime prevention, the various failures of the Bush administration, NAFTA trucking, Catholic bishops meddling and California's instructive demography.

Reporter Kitty Pilgrim even criticized the Southern Poverty Law Center ($PLC) for misreporting hate crimes. That segment surely added to the $PLC’s commitment to the Raza version of the Long Knives.

Beyond immigration, LDT featured other under-reported subjects, such as Second Amendment rights, globalist trade, Red Chinese espionage, country-of-origin food labeling, free speech on campus and the shrinking middle class.

In suppressing LDT, the enemies of the American nation have won a round. Keeping honest immigration reporting off television must tend to lower public awareness of the issue, since 71 percent of the public get most of their news from TV.

Let me be clear: LDT was far from perfect. It did top-notch coverage on the topics it chose to investigate. But it avoided large areas of the immigration issue, in particular the environment and cultural differences. Reporting of those issues tended to be occasional and peripheral.

My misgivings were the subject of the June 2008 article, "Triple" Legal Immigration? Say It Ain't So, Lou Dobbs. For someone so identified with the subject, Dobbs' indifference toward the consequences of rapid population growth was very troubling indeed.

Nevertheless, inquiring Americans now don't even have the flawed LDT because of network cowardice about criticism.

Diversity may be strength, but it is not conducive to free speech. Since the beginning of the year, two Scandinavian cartoonists (Lars Vilks and Kurt Westergaard) were physically attacked in their homes for drawing pictures of Mohammed.

American network executives suffer no such threats. But they cower in fear in the face of complaints, no matter how spurious.

Patriotic citizens would be in a terrible fix—if not for the internet, and alternative publications like VDARE.COM.

Brenda Walker (email her) lives in Northern California and publishes two websites, LimitsToGrowth.org and ImmigrationsHumanCost.org. She fears we haven't seen the last of Lou Dobbs.

If you want to email or print out, format by clicking on this permanent URL:
http://www.vdare.com/walker/100318_blackout.htm

************

VDARE Archives

 
Author's Archive
(See also Editorial Collective)
"An Economist" Archive
Chuck Baldwin Archive
Paul Belien Archive
Boethius Archive
Peter Bradley Archive
Patrick J. Buchanan Archive
Kevin Carter Archive
Donald A. Collins Archive
John Derbyshire Archive
F. Roger Devlin Archive
Marcus Epstein Archive
Sam Francis Archive
Sean Gabb Archive
Peter Gadiel Archive
Eugene Girin Archive
Virgil Goode Archive
Dave Gorak Archive
Paul Gottfried Archive
Kevin Michael Grace Archive
Alexander Hart Archive
Carl Horowitz Archive
Richard Hoste Archive
Lincoln Kahn Archive
Martin Kelly Archive
Ryan Kennedy Archive
Kevin Lamb Archive
Robert Locke Archive
Ellison Lodge Archive
Richard Lynn Archive
Kevin MacDonald Archive
Michelle Malkin Archive
Scott McConnell Archive
Henry McCulloch Archive
Hugh McInnish Archive
Ilana Mercer Archive
John Miano Archive
Paul Nachman Archive
Tom Piatak Archive
Matthew Richer Archive
Edwin S. Rubenstein Archive
J. Philippe Rushton Archive
Mike Scruggs Archive
Takuan Seiyo Archive
Kathy Shaidle Archive
Cooper Sterling Archive
Nicholas Stix Archive
R. J. Stove Archive
J. Paige Straley Archive
Jared Taylor Archive
Linda Thom Archive
Washington Watcher Archive
David Wilson Archive
David Yeagley Archive
John Zmirak Archive
 
Yearly Archives
2010 2009
2008 2007
2006 2005
2004 2003
2002 2001
2000 1999
ALL Letters

Labor & Immigration Archive

Libertarians and Immigration Archive

 

************

Sign up for our Email Newsletter

ListBuilder, our email bulletin tool, has a tendency to quarrel with some readers’ ISPs, especially because of the recent spam epidemic. If you do not receive your bulletin, please sign up again. If problems persist, please let us know. Bulletins are archived here.

************

We welcome correspondence and read everything (but can't always answer, alas). Please note if you would prefer us not to post it and if you want your e-mail address excluded. For publication: witan@vdare.com  Not for publication: editnp@vdare.com.

************

Donations are tax-deductible and can be made online by credit card or via mail.

************

VDARE Web Master

************

Although care has been taken in preparing the information contained in this site and in selecting links to other web sites, this information is supplied without warranty. Click here for more boring stuff our lawyers want you to read.

************

 

Ring of Conservative Sites
[ Prev | Skip Prev | Prev 5 | List |
Rand | Next 5 | Skip Next | Next ]


member of the Ring Of Immigration Issues Web Sites
[ Prev | Next ]
[Skip 1 Site] [List Sites] [ Join Now | Ring Hub | Random