Opinion



March 17, 2010, 9:00 pm

The Purists

Timothy EganTimothy Egan on American politics and life, as seen from the West.

Dennis KucinichAssociated Press Dennis Kucinich leaving Air Force One on Monday.

Quite a week for Dennis Kucinich, the liberal Democratic congressman who had been threatening to do to health care what Ralph Nader did to Al Gore in 2000.

On Monday, he accompanied President Obama on Air Force One, flying to his district in Cleveland for a rally.

On Wednesday, he ended months of self-righteous defiance, deciding not to stand with every single Republican in Congress trying to block health care reform.

Until the last minute, it looked like even an executive sky ride would not move the pure heart of Dennis Kucinich. When you’ve seen a U.F.O., as Kucinich says he has, a mere lobbying session at 32,000 feet by the Leader of the Free World, urging you to join your party in a cause that has eluded Democratic presidents since Franklin Roosevelt, is a tough match.

But let’s give him credit — he swallowed his pride and switched. Obama may not yet have the defining legislation of his presidency on his desk, but he’s already pulled off a small miracle: getting the holier-than-thou purists of his party to realize that they have to govern every now and then.

No such problems on the Republican side. Health care? It’s not even a debate point. They’re all for the status quo. In lock-step. Out in Arizona, where Senator John McCain is fending off a primary fight by the bombastic J.D. Hayworth, the obsession of the moment concerns whether gay marriage would allow a man to marry a horse — at least that’s how Hayworth sees it.

And even Republicans who had supported the philosophical framework of the plan now inching toward the finish line in Congress — that’s you, Mitt Romney, former Massachusetts governor and co-architect of the state’s near-identical health program — have fled to the thumb-sucking safety of the ideological playpen.

Ah, to be among the true believers, breathing only the clean air of sanctimony. Nothing is ever done, no lives improved, no laws passed. No messy deals tarnished by the poison of compromise. The public hates you — every poll shows that voters want both sides to legislate with a mix of ideas. But, oh, how good it must feel to be right all the time.

For most of his career, Kucinich has been a snow-white liberal. And it shows: after his nearly 14 years in Congress, his accomplishments could not fill the toe-end of a sock. Now, his vote could actually make a difference to the people in his congressional district who lack health care — about 90,000 or more if it follows the national average. They would have the right to buy the same coverage that Kucinich gets through his sweat-free job in Congress. Imagine.

“It’s not an easy burden he has taken up,” Kucinich said of Obama on Wednesday. “One of the things that has bothered me has been the attempt to delegitimize his presidency.”

No kidding. None of the great bipartisan triumphs of the past — Social Security, Medicare, the Civil Rights Act — would have a prayer in the present environment. That’s not how we do politics in 2010. We talk, loudly, only to like-minded partisans, and everyone else be damned.

If Kucinich had gone ahead as promised with a “no” vote, it would not have an asterisk next to it. It would simply be another no, putting him in league with Michele Bachmann, John Boehner and other congressional defenders of the costliest, most inefficient and least accessible health care system in the Western world.

Bachmann, who makes the nutty-news sidebar every time she opens her mouth, is the conservative doppelganger to the liberal purist. She can say crazy things — e.g., her claim that swine flu and Democratic presidents suggest a conspiracy of sorts — and actually get applause in her cocoon of kooks.

Reality is always a problem for purists. On the liberal side, many fail to comprehend that they are a distinct minority, stuck for years at around 19 percent of the public. When a liberal like Obama gets elected, he has to govern as a centrist for the simple reason that four-fifths of the country does not share his basic political outlook.

Smart liberals understand this. No one has been more passionate and consistent in favor of a single-payer universal health care system than Jim McDermott, the left-leaning congressman from Seattle.

But when the final health care tally is made, McDermott told me he plans to put aside his own concerns and vote for something less than perfect, rather than wait another 30 years.

“I always knew that we would need a fallback position,” he said, adding that he had “always considered myself a pragmatist to the core.”

These are easy votes for McDermott and Kucinich. To get into political trouble in their safe districts, they would have to do something like propose a national monument in honor of John Edwards.

Real courage is the first-term Democratic member of Congress in a Republican-leaning district who stands to lose the seat by voting for health care. There may be a dozen or more of those members who will walk the line by Saturday’s final vote.

A telling moment for Kucinich and Obama came during a presidential primary debate two years ago. After Kucinich admitted he had, in fact, seen a U.F.O. — it hovered silently overhead near the home of noted pragmatist Shirley MacLaine — Obama was asked if he believed in life on other planets.

He said he wasn’t sure, but what he did know was that there was plenty of life on this planet that needed help. Kucinich, in switching his vote, has for the moment decided to stop staring at saucers. Beam him up.


Timothy Egan worked for The Times for 18 years – as Pacific Northwest correspondent and a national enterprise reporter. His column on American politics and life as seen from the West Coast appears here on Thursdays. In 2001, he was part of the Pulitzer Prize-winning team that wrote the series “How Race Is Lived in America.” He is the author of several books, including “The Worst Hard Time,” a history of the Dust Bowl, for which he won the National Book Award, and most recently, “The Big Burn: Teddy Roosevelt and the Fire That Saved America.”

Inside Opinionator

March 19, 2010
Don’t Move! If You Know What’s Good for You

There are times when you want to stay right where you are.

February 5, 2010
Oh, What a Lovely Mess!

NBC’s recent adventures in talk-show-host management remind one former talk-show host of his own adventures in prime time with another network.

January 22, 2010
Awesome, and Then Some

An on-set encounter with John Wayne revealed an unexpected side of the actor.

More From Dick Cavett »

March 18, 2010
Lehman’s Demise, Dissected

If simple incentives had been in place on Wall Street, could the latest crisis have been largely avoided?

March 4, 2010
A Wall Street Witch Hunt

In 1987, Goldman Sachs made headlines for an insider trading arrest case marked by prosecutorial excess.

February 18, 2010
The Great Goldman Sachs Fire Sale of 2008

If everything was really under control after Lehman collapsed, why were Goldman executives dumping their stock by the bushelful?

More From William D. Cohan »

March 17, 2010
The Purists

With purists at both ends of the political spectrum making it hard to govern, Dennis Kucinich’s reversal on health-care legislation seems brave, if overdue.

March 3, 2010
L.A. Consequential

Los Angeles is safer than it’s been in decades, having so far avoided the dire future many had predicted in the ’90s.

February 24, 2010
The Missionary Impulse

Zealous amateurs have damaged the efforts of more legitimate adoption services and relief agencies in Haiti.

More From Timothy Egan »

March 17, 2010
Is Passing the Health Care Bill Really a Bad Idea?

Gail Collins tries to talk David Brooks off the ledge.

March 12, 2010
Is the U.S. Following in Rome’s Footsteps?

Americans are in a bad mood. Is there a bright side?

March 5, 2010
In What Can We Trust?

Searching for reasons to be pessimistic these days is pretty easy.

More From The Conversation »

March 16, 2010
Christian Soldiers

The strategy that underlies many missionaries’ reverence for Allah.

March 9, 2010
Toyotas Are Safe (Enough)

A closer look at the statistics on death from sudden acceleration reveals why there’s little need to fear driving a Toyota.

February 23, 2010
The First Tea-Party Terrorist?

The man who crashed a small plane into an Austin I.R.S. office hoped to inspire an overreaction.

More From Robert Wright »

March 16, 2010
Divide and Diminish

The human impulse to parcel nature into smaller and smaller plots is a danger to biodiversity.

March 9, 2010
Breezy Love, or the Sacking of the Bees

The wind-pollination of flowers is a fascinating process, though perhaps less so if you suffer from allergies.

March 2, 2010
Evolution by the Grassroots

March’s Life-form of the Month is wildly successful, hugely influential and pretty much everywhere: grass.

More From Olivia Judson »

March 15, 2010
Pragmatism’s Gift

Is pragmatism just an academic philosophy, or can it help us live improved lives?

March 8, 2010
Do You Miss Him Yet?

As predicted, signs of nostalgia for George W. Bush.

March 1, 2010
Little Big Men

Many larger-than-life tough guys of the screen, it seems, just don’t measure up.

More From Stanley Fish »

March 11, 2010
Clarence Thomas, Silent but Sure

Justice Clarence Thomas has been silent on the bench, but his opinion that the Eighth Amendment doesn’t protect prisoners from harsh treatment is clear in his writing.

February 25, 2010
Missing the Tea Party

The Supreme Court’s campaign finance ruling has both angered conservatives and given the Obama administration an opportunity.

February 11, 2010
Saved by the Swiss

With some last-minute maneuvering, the Obama administration looks as if it will avoid a test of the limits of executive power at the Supreme Court.

More From Linda Greenhouse »

Steven Strogatz
Think Globally
March 21, 2010
All-Nighters
Why We Need to Dream
March 19, 2010
The Thread
Checking the Math on Health Care
March 19, 2010
All-Nighters
At Midnight, All the Doctors…
March 18, 2010
Home Fires
A Small Victory in Afghanistan
March 17, 2010

All Contributors »

Opinionator Highlights

Why We Need to Dream

Those fantastical nighttime narratives have a practical purpose after all.

Thumbnail
A Small Victory in Afghanistan

As life slowly returns to a once devastated town in Afghanistan, a Marine who fought there takes solace.

Night Lights, Blankets and Lullabies

How children, and their parents, cope with the nightly passage into sleep.

In the Night Kitchen

Baking from memory in the wee hours of the morning.

Thumbnail
The A-to-Z Cure

Instead of counting sheep, listing ailments.