OPINIONS

Avoid racial fetishism on Valentine’s Day

Last Valentine’s Day, I entered a committed relationship with myself after a disappointing holiday with a cisgender, heterosexual, white male, who later revealed to me that he could not date me because I was black. He felt that the color of my skin and history of my people would upset his father enough to stop paying his tuition. I’ve told this story to my family, friends and the entire class of 2018 during FACES in order to heal, and the reactions have been mixed.

Some expressed sympathy for him, saying that it’s not his fault that his father is racist. Some have gone as far as to say that this person himself was not racist. A mutual friend offered insight by providing this analogy: “It’s kind of like growing up a conservative Christian and realizing you are gay. You can’t help that you’re gay, but you feel really bad about it because you were taught to believe that it’s wrong.”

You can choose as a white person to not date a person of color because you believe their race is inferior. You can be racist. But don’t pursue people of color because their “deviance” turns you on. The situation still makes me cringe because his beliefs did not stop him from pursuing me like forbidden fruit.

Racial fetishism: The indulgence of people of color by members of the dominant group based on racist notions, discrimination and stereotypes drenched in a history of oppression.

No matter what weak excuses others have to give for my freshman year experience, his actions are unjust. He is at fault, and so especially is his father.  I have no sympathy for racial fetishes. As a black woman, my history of sexual oppression in America cannot be a separated from the interactions I have on this campus.

The three most referenced stereotypes of black women are Mammy, Jezebel and Sapphire. The Mammy, popularly recognized in “Gone with the Wind,” is desexualized, maternal and nurturing to everyone. She was conceived in slavery as the caregiver for her owner’s children. The Jezebel is hyper-sexualized, seductive and always available for sex. She powers the myth, also from slavery, that it is impossible for a black woman to be raped. The Sapphire is “the wise-cracking, balls-crushing, emasculating woman, is usually shown with her hands on her hips and her head thrown back as she lets everyone know she is in charge.”

In the context of all of my interracial interactions on campus, I have been morphed into all three. I expect strangers to confine and categorize me, but am troubled to experience this in friendships and romances. The two that played out the most romantically and infringed upon my safety were the Jezebel and Sapphire. Because of the Jezebel, I’ve had to fight for my right to choice and protect the sacredness of my body. The Sapphire causes others to see me as combative and not worthy of protection and to never take my concerns seriously.

The longing for the imaginary Jezebel is what fueled the desire for my affections in my freshman year romantic interest. That is racism. There is no question about it. Essayist, journalist and activist, s.e. smith sums it up the best:

“Someone who says he (and it is usually a he) ‘prefers’ women of a specific race…[is] viewing certain kinds of women as dateable material on the basis of racial discrimination; and it’s telling that most men with racial ‘preferences’ — which are really racial fetishes — use very racist, stereotypical descriptions when talking about why they ‘prefer’ women of specific races. Asian women are meek, say, or Latinas are fiery, or Black women are exotic and know how to deliver in bed.”

Racial fetishism happens among Stanford students. It happens at parties, in the dorms, and it lives in hookups and comments among friends. It doesn’t only happen among men. Women are guilty of racial fetishism and objectification of men, specifically black men. Racism comes in many forms and a spectrum of degrees. Sexually and romantically, racism is alive and well.

Acknowledge it. Confront it. Don’t do it. Recognize if it is being done to you. And have a fantastic Valentine’s Day.

Contact Mysia Anderson at mysia ‘at’ stanford.edu.

About Mysia Anderson

Mysia Anderson '17 is a sophomore majoring in African & African American studies. She is from Miami, Florida and is an unapologetic Black feminist. She enjoys poems about love, free food, and dancing to Beyoncé. You can contact Mysia at mysia@stanford.edu.
  • RM

    This article upsets me. I don’t feel it speaks to the diversity of human experience and the duplicitous capacity for love and harm within all persons. I feel accused of opinions, beliefs and presumptions that I do not hold. I would prefer that this article be removed from the Daily, but in the interest of free speech, I will settle for this expression of my discontent. If you read this article and were also upset, please react with sympathy and avoid hateful or inflammatory comments. RM

  • Victimology Class

    lol Mysia. Your CSRE teachers are all teaching you that the world has it out for you, but in reality, that’s called life. All of us deal with shit. Grow the fuck up and deal with it.

  • student

    This person gets it

  • Candid One

    Your comment works well to reinforce the broader issues behind this editorial. Your sensitivities are primary, huh? Reread your comment later and perhaps your duplicity will register. How are the broader historical legacies embodied in this column not inflammatory? How can they not be inflammatory? Myriad individuals are continually experiencing the realities that you don’t want to acknowledge–doesn’t such attitude preserve such legacies? How is it that you should be protected but not them? Of course, there wasn’t a decorous intent by the writer…what is decorous about the issues involved? You have prerogative to be “upset” but not the writer? Uh-huh.

  • Candid One

    Clueless much?

  • My thoughts

    Maybe your assumption about him being cisgender and heterosexual is wrong and he actually dumped you because he is trans or gay.

    My main point is– why is it okay to throw labels on him (“racist, cisgender, heterosexual”) but you’re not okay with him conceiving you as a Jezebel, or a Sapphire, or what have you.

  • james

    What even is this? You’re mad about something. Something happened you don’t like. There’s something people should do and shouldn’t do or think or feel because you say so. This is a weird mixture of assertions, accusations, and declarations untethered to any reasoned argument. You might have a good point about something–I can’t tell–but if you want people to care about what you have to say, you need to learn how to write coherently and think critically first.

  • ML

    Mysia,

    Your article resonates with me. Your experience with your romantic interest must have been heartbreaking. It’s hard enough to deal with the “normal scale” of break-up feelings–but to add a racial element to that mix? It’s cruel. I can only imagine how devastating it must have felt for you to be told that the reason you weren’t dating this person was because of this innate part of yourself that you can’t change–even if you ever wanted to. It’s one thing to break-up because of some perceived incompatibility that masks underlying indifference (like not having the same music tastes, or something equally surface), but quite another to have a person tell you that you are inherently “not right” for them, so to speak.

    I can’t imagine how it must have felt for you. I’ve had a very similar experience, and the damage that break-up and the reasoning behind it wrought upon me is deep. Months later, I sometimes thought about how it was “my fault” that we couldn’t be together–because I’m black. Logically, I know that this isn’t true, but it’s often hard to overcome these deep-seeded psychological hurts. I’ve had to remind myself that it’s not “my fault”, because I love every ounce of who I am, and I would never want to not be black. I’ve had to remind myself that not wanting to date someone because of their race is racist. That the blame lies with the society that created these racist stereotypes, and with the person who doesn’t try to overcome them, and with the person who–knowing that he’s racist–pursues women of a race that he knows will ultimately be “unsuitable” in his eyes, and promptly discarded.
    I truly, truly feel for you.

    I want to add one thing. It’s possible that I’m making a very large and inaccurate assumption about you, and if so, please accept my apologies and disregard the following. But from the latter part of this article I detected a lot of hatred and distrust of white people in general. You talk about how in your interracial interactions, all caucasians try to fit you into a trope of black women–the Jezebel or the Sapphire. I just hope that you know that not all white people are like this boy who you were involved with. I know that for a fact. I hope you know that characterizing all white people as a universally malicious, racist people who only see black women as hypersexualized types and items is prejudiced. I hope you don’t, because of this interaction with your freshman romantic interest, avoid all white people and assume that they are all not-to-be-trusted and hateful. But mostly, I hope that you are okay, and that you never are never in a situation where you feel like that boy made you feel ever again. Peace.

  • mogden

    Any article that contains “cisgender” in the first sentence is sure to induce fits of hilarity in the discerning reader, and this one is no exception.

  • Haha

    LOL

  • Jezebel Muncher

    Mysia, I love you :)

  • Student

    Does the Daily have any editors or an EIC?

  • 09

    Your account of your previous relationship might be accurate, but we can’t really decide until we’ve heard your ex’s side of the story.