| Season | Player • Position |
| 1952 | Sam Morley • E |
| 1953 (3) | Bob Garrett • Back |
| Sam Morley • E | |
| John Steinberg • E | |
| 1954 | John Stewart • E |
| 1955 (2) | Bill Tarr • Back |
| Paul Wiggin • T | |
| 1956 (2) | John Brodie • Back |
| Paul Wiggin • T | |
| 1957 | Troy Barbee • T |
| 1958 | Chris Burford • E |
| 1959 | Chris Burford • E |
| 1960 | Skip Face • FB |
| 1961 | George Honor • E |
| 1962 (2) | Ed Cummings • Specialist |
| Marv Harris • G | |
| 1963 (2) | Marv Harris • C |
| Frank Patitucci • E | |
| 1964 (4) | Jack Chapple • LB |
| Ray Handley • FB | |
| Gary Pettigrew • DT | |
| Dick Ragsdale • DB | |
| 1965 (2) | Marty Brill • LB |
| Blaine Nye • DT | |
| 1967 (2) | Mike Hibler • DT |
| Gene Washington • WR | |
| 1968 (3) | Don Parish • LB |
| Malcolm Snider • OT | |
| Gene Washington • WR | |
| 1969 (5) | Rick Keller • DB |
| Bob Moore • WR | |
| Don Parish • LB | |
| Jim Plunkett • QB | |
| John Sande III • C | |
| 1970 (6) | Steve Jubb • OT |
| Bob Moore • WR | |
| Jim Plunkett • QB | |
| Jeff Siemon • LB | |
| Dave Tipton • DT | |
| Randy Vataha • FL | |
| 1971 (4) | Don Bunce • QB |
| Larry Butler • DT | |
| Pete Lazetich • DT | |
| Jeff Siemon • LB | |
| 1972 (3) | Rod Garcia • PK |
| Jim Merlo • LB | |
| Randy Poltl • DB | |
| 1973 (5) | Mike Boryla • QB |
| Rod Garcia • PK | |
| Randy Poltl • DB | |
| Bill Singler • WR | |
| Roger Stillwell • DE | |
| 1974 (2) | Pat Donovan • DE |
| Gordon Riegel • LB | |
| 1975 (6) | Geb Church • LB |
| Tony Hill • WR | |
| Alex Karakazoff • OG | |
| Mike Langford • PK | |
| Duncan McColl • DE | |
| Ted Pappas • TE | |
| 1976 (3) | Tony Hill • WR |
| Alex Karakazoff • OG | |
| Duncan McColl • DE | |
| 1977 (5) | Guy Benjamin • QB |
| Gordy Ceresino • LB | |
| Gordon King • OT | |
| James Lofton • WR | |
| Darrin Nelson • RB | |
| 1978 (3) | Gordy Ceresino • LB |
| Ken Margerum • WR | |
| Darrin Nelson • RB | |
| 1979 (2) | Ken Margerum • WR |
| Ken Naber • PK/P | |
| 1980 (6) | John Elway • QB |
| Brian Holloway • OT | |
| John Macaulay • C | |
| Ken Margerum • WR | |
| Darrin Nelson • RB | |
| Andre Tyler • WR | |
| 1981 (2) | Darrin Nelson • RB |
| Vaughn Williams • DB | |
| 1982 (4) | Chris Dressel • TE |
| John Elway • QB | |
| Vincent White • RB | |
| Vaughn Williams • DB | |
| 1984 (2) | Brent Martin • OT |
| Garin Veris • DE | |
| 1985 (3) | John Barns • OT |
| Greg Baty • TE | |
| Brad Muster • RB | |
| 1986 (4) | Thomas Henley • Specialist |
| Brad Muster • RB | |
| Tony Leiker • DT | |
| Dave Wyman • LB | |
| 1987 (2) | Alan Grant • Specialist |
| Brad Humphreys • DB | |
| 1988 (2) | Rob Hinckley • OLB |
| Jon Volpe • RB | |
| 1990 (4) | Ed McCaffrey • WR |
| Glyn Milburn • RB | |
| Kevin Scott • CB | |
| Bob Whitfield • OT | |
| 1991 (3) | Ron George • OLB |
| Tommy Vardell • FB | |
| Bob Whitfield • OT | |
| 1992 (3) | Ron George • OLB |
| John Lynch • FS | |
| Glyn Milburn • RB | |
| 1994 | Justin Armour • WR |
| 1995 (3) | Eric Abrams • PK |
| Jeff Buckey • OT | |
| Damon Dunn • Specialist | |
| 1996 | Kailee Wong • DE |
| 1997 (2) | Troy Walters • Specialist |
| Kailee Wong • DE | |
| 1999 (7) | Mike Biselli • PK |
| Emory Brock • Specialist | |
| Jeff Cronshagen • OT | |
| Willie Howard • DT | |
| Todd Husak • QB | |
| Mike McLaughlin • C | |
| Troy Walters • FL | |
| 2000 (3) | Willie Howard • DT |
| Riall Johnson • OLB | |
| DeRonnie Pitts • WR | |
| 2001 (4) | Brian Allen • KR |
| Eric Heitmann • OG | |
| Tank Williams • FS | |
| Coy Wire • ILB | |
| 2002 | Kwame Harris • OT |
| 2004 (3) | Michael Okwo • Specialist |
| T.J. Rushing • KR | |
| Alex Smith • TE | |
| 2005 | Timi Wusu • Specialist |
| 2006 (2) | Michael Okwo • Linebacker |
| Wopamo Osaisai • Specialist | |
| 2008 | Ben Muth • OT |
| 2009 (3) | Toby Gerhart • RB |
| Chris Marinelli • OT | |
| Chris Owusu • KR | |
| 2010 (7) | Chike Amajoyi • ST |
| Chase Beeler • C | |
| David DeCastro • RG | |
| Andrew Luck • QB | |
| Owen Marecic • RB | |
| Jonathan Martin • LT | |
| Nate Whitaker • K | |
| 2011 (6) | David DeCastro • OL |
| Delano Howell • DB | |
| Coby Fleener • TE | |
| Andrew Luck • QB | |
| Jonathan Martin • OL | |
| Chase Thomas • LB | |
| 2012 (5) | Zach Ertz • TE |
| Trent Murphy • LB | |
| Ed Reynolds • DB | |
| Chase Thomas • LB | |
| David Yankey • OL | |
| 2013 (6) | Ben Gardner • DT |
| Ty Montgomery • KR | |
| Trent Murphy • OLB | |
| Ed Reynolds • FS | |
| Shayne Skov • ILB | |
| David Yankey • OT |
