Education



June 3, 2011, 4:36 am

How Do You Feel About Proms?

DRESS-UP Danielle Gordon, 18, a senior in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, in her prom dress from Notte by Marchesa.Robert Wright for The New York TimesDRESS-UP Danielle Gordon, 18, a senior in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, in her prom dress from Notte by Marchesa. Go to related article »
Student Opinion - The Learning NetworkStudent Opinion - The Learning Network

Questions about issues in the news for students 13 and older.

Does your school have a prom? Will you be going? If you’re going, what are you wearing, and about how much do you expect to spend? How do you feel about formal school dances in general? Why?

In “The Prom Dress Moves Into the Designer Leagues,” Marisa Meltzer writes:

Last year, as a junior at the Latin School in Chicago, Colby Jordan wore a black silk gown designed by John Galliano with matching Dior heels to prom. “This year I’m switching gears,” she said on the phone from her home recently. “I’m doing a chartreuse Roland Mouret gown with purple snakeskin YSL Tribute sandals.”

As at the Oscars, the school has a tradition of students changing outfits for after-parties, so Ms. Jordan, 18, is also considering a white Herve Leger dress with silver heels by Azzedine Alaïa bought during Paris Fashion Week last March, plus jewelry from a “dear friend,” the New York designer Eddie Borgo, who lent her pieces when she attended the Met Ball earlier this month.

While Ms. Jordan is a rare, jet-set teenager attending such exclusive events, she’s not the only one buying a designer dress, often costing in the mid-three figures or higher, for prom night.

Students: Tell us your feelings about and experiences with formal school dances like proms. Is there a trend toward wearing designer dresses at your school? Do you think there is too much pressure and cost associated with proms, or do you tend to agree with the woman in the article who says that prom is a girl’s “first magical Cinderella-evening moment”?


Students 13 and older are invited to comment below. Please use only your first name. For privacy policy reasons, we will not publish student comments that include a last name.

Teachers: Here are ten ways to teach with this feature.


10 Comments

  1. 1. June 3, 2011 11:01 am Link

    I think prom is fun and it should just be for seniors to make it more special. The whole designer dress thing makes no sense to me get a dress you like and were ever you happen to find it. They also should be appropriate not short little night gowns.

    — Katie216
  2. 2. June 3, 2011 11:02 am Link

    I don’t really like proms, because there boring, pretty much all you do is just stand around and do nothing. The only thing that I like about is that I get to dance with the girls. I don’t mind having to dress up, but still I just find proms super boring. Sometimes they don’t play hardly any good music.

    — Zechariah.T (216)
  3. 3. June 3, 2011 11:02 am Link

    I think its fine to where desiner dresses because if its what u want to weir u should weir it but if u cant afford it weir something else its not like any one will notace

    — katelyn 216
  4. 4. June 3, 2011 11:05 am Link

    I think senior prom is something that every high school student should go to. I think even if your not that into dances, or never went to the other little dances, its still important to go to prom. Prom has happened at high schools for years, its nothing new. It’s for you and your friends to have that last dance and have a good time. I know some other smaller schools , they let everybody go to prom, but I think it should just be seniors and their date they choose to bring.I think if the whole school can go it’s not very special for when you are in your senior year. I know I plan on going to my prom, its exciting to me. I think that prom you should spend a little more money on your dress and everything.I’m not sure what dress im getting for my prom since its not for two more years, but I have a pretty good idea.Overall I think prom is a good thing to have, while your in high school.

    — myoung216
  5. 5. June 3, 2011 11:08 am Link

    For me prom is an amazing and such a fun experience. Getting all dressed up and ready to have fun with a close friend or the person you care about most for is just such a blast. I have not had my own prom yet but I cannot wait until then because I know how much fun it will be. Prom is something you can look back on and realize all the amazing times you had and so many memories. For me prom is such an amazing thing, and I can’t wait until my own!

    — jay 216
  6. 6. June 3, 2011 11:11 am Link

    I feel that prom is great event top go to. It is time to dance, eat, and have fun with friends for the night. You can get all dressed up and go out. It is a great exprience for everyone to enjoy.

    — Darius
  7. 7. June 3, 2011 11:12 am Link

    I think that proms are overrated when it comes to spending 700$ on a dress. i think that no high school girl should spend that much on a dress that you will ware for one night. I also think that buying a dress for an after part is also a bit ridicules.

    — Nate.S (216)
  8. 8. June 3, 2011 11:12 am Link

    I like the idea of the prom. Getting all dressed up for a large event, paying $20 a ticket, spending time with good friends, making memories, taking a million pictures, along with the after parties. First the country club for a few hours, then the backyard concert down the road until daybreak, awaiting the intense headache and the yelling parent, the next morning, wondering where you were all night. Your only excuse that’ll ever make sense will probably be the one where you fell asleep on a bench in the park. I suppose that’s better than the one where you fell asleep on the pool table, staining that rental tux in the chip dip.
    All in all, a good time had by all. Friends leave for college, some for service, others dragging on their life wherever it takes them. Never know if you’ll see them again, but always having those memories of that last night before you all go off.

    — Emerson
  9. 9. June 3, 2011 1:45 pm Link

    I think every high school should have a prom. For the girls its more of a big night. Getting all dressed up, picking out a dress that fits you perfectly, all the wonderful memories shared as the year comes to an end. Prom is really exciting to think about. I can not wait to go to my prom. It is one of the most big events of the senior year and every student should experience prom. Who knows after prom you may not see some of your friends for a while.

    — Domenique
  10. 10. June 3, 2011 4:05 pm Link

    I like the idea of prom but I did not go to mine. I think that this article shows what an unfortunate state the youth are in today. These girls are the ones that will eventually be in charge of a lot of things and all they can do is waste enormous amounts of money on expensive dresses. It’s sad.

    — Vard

Add your comments...

Required

Required, will not be published

This Week on The Learning Network

Announcement
Found Poem Challenge

We'll begin publishing our favorites on May 31, and will publish a new favorite every day through June 13.

Query
Summer Reading

What's on your summer reading list? Teachers and students, weigh in and we'll compile and publish both lists!

About The Learning Network

The Learning Network provides teaching and learning materials and ideas based on New York Times content.

Teachers can use or adapt our lessons across subject areas and levels. Students can respond to our Opinion questions, take our News Quizzes, learn the Word of the Day, try our Test Yourself questions, complete a Fill-In or read our Poetry Pairings.

Join the conversation by commenting on any post. We'd love to hear what you think!

Comments of the Moment

“ I like the idea of the prom. Getting all dressed up for a large event, paying $20 a ticket, spending time with good friends, making memories, taking a million pictures, along with the after parties. First the country club for a few hours, then the backyard concert down the road until daybreak, awaiting the intense headache and the yelling parent, the next morning, wondering where you were all night. Your only excuse that'll ever make sense will probably be the one where you fell asleep on a bench in the park. I suppose that's better than the one where you fell asleep on the pool table, staining that rental tux in the chip dip. ”
— Emerson
How Do You Feel About Proms?
“ Ok, I am, kind of a “dork” myself, but I do not know why but some people think I am popular. Just yesterday some 5th grade girls said "hi Chad," and a long with many other people that say “Hi Chad.” I literally have to come to school everyday with some random stranger saying hi Chad, hi Chad, and just to top it off hi Chad. To tell you the truth, I am almost sick of my name. So when I asked them “How do you know my name?” Then another one said, “We know you ‘cause you’re popular.” Ok I am not that popular. When I was driving to school with my mom on the first day of middle school. I was terrified. ”
— chad
Are You Popular, Quirky or Conformist?
“ Um I don't believe I have a life calling. If I had a choice for what to do with the rest of my life, I would like it to do with movies. I live and breathe movies...as soon as I see a movie I can quote any line of any scene. When I grow up, I would like to be a movie critic. ”
— Jackieee
Do You Have a Life Calling?
“ It's all professional reading for the first half of summer. Lots of fascinating history for a workshop. Here's a photo. http://www.flickr.com/photos/mrsdkrebs/5787150857/in/photostream”
— Denise Krebs
Teachers, What's on Your Summer Reading List?
“ I think that reading on my swing in the backyard is one of the simple joys of summer. I have been reading a series called “The Secret Series” by Pseudonymous Bosch, and I plan to finish the series by reading the last book this summer. ”
— Caitlin
What's on Your Summer Reading List?
“ I'm a fan of Steve Jobs and my motto is his famous words "Your time is limited, so don't wasted living someone else's life, don't be trapped by dogma which is living with the results of other people's thinking, don't let other's opinion drown out your own inner voice, and most important, have the courage to follow your heart and intuition, they somehow already know what you truly want to become." ”
— Ying
Do You Have a Life Calling?
“ I'm prepping a course called "Better Than The Book?" that looks at films based on books, so those types of titles are heavy on my list: In Cold Blood, Lolita, The Orchid Thief One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, Leaving Las Vegas and others are topping the list right now. I'm also reading "The Warmth of Other Suns" by Isabel Wilkerson and a few other, non-school related titles.”
— Dave Copeland
Teachers, What's on Your Summer Reading List?
“ Great first poem! I love reading kids' poetry, these will be fun to read!!!”
— Jennifer
Found Poem Favorite | 'Broken Record'
“ The biggest advantage I've noticed that comes from having studied so many languages is that I'm really really good at identifying patterns and puzzles and figuring out how different things relate to each other.”
— Thomas
Do You Speak a Second, or Third, Language?
“ ...if I have to organize something or make a list, I often do it in German, same for counting. When expressing emotions or thinking about emotions English feels much more natural. German has a super rich abundance of sayings, proverbs and idioms, I miss that in English. Speaking another language fluently or well is not just a way to communicate - it changes your understanding of that culture, of your own language, of the respective limitations and advantages.”
— Kat
Do You Speak a Second, or Third, Language?
“ A secondhand thing that I have acquired is a puppy golden retriever. That dog was our first pet in my six family house. We named this dog Jeter after the Yankee shortstop Derek Jeter. This dog has been one of the best things that has happened in my life.”
— Mackenzie
What Are the Best Things You've Acquired Secondhand?
“ The best thing I got that was secondhand was my first baseball glove. My dad gave me his glove from when he was a kid and I knew it was special. It was gold and made of leather and I took a lot of care of it. ”
— Kiran
What Are the Best Things You've Acquired Secondhand?
“ I love edmodo as a twitter like program for the classroom environment. The kids join a group using a code and then they can send messages (which can be text, video, embedded projects, etc) within the group. Then other students can respond and give feedback. Not only can it be used within a classroom or school but also with a wider audience of other classes. Several elementary classes from around the US joined up to do an online book club this school year. We all read the same books and the kids posted questions, responses and related projects within the edmodo groups. It was great fun and then we even did a Skype call with one of the classes so we could meet them "in person."”
— Heather T
Less Is More: Using Social Media to Inspire Concise Writing
“ I speak three languages: Bangla (my mother tongue), English and Thai (I have lived in Thailand for 13 years). I do not necessarily think in one all the time, but the language I am using currently for work will determine the language I am thinking in.”
— Wahid
Do You Speak a Second, or Third, Language?
“ I think, speak, read, and write fluently in three languages(English-my strongest, French, and Spanish) and also studied German for 3 years and now have studied Italian for 4 semesters in my free time at a local college. Knowing multiple languages is a definite advantage and I find that I am a much more lucid thinker and retain information, even peoples' names, much better than my coworkers or friends for example who often seem "forgetful". Furthermore, I seem to be able to find the right words to complete other's thoughts. This gives me a definite "thinking" advantage. But most of all, speaking and reading in different languages makes life and social interactions a great deal more interesting and FUN!! ”
— patti
Do You Speak a Second, or Third, Language?

Archive

Recent Posts

June 03

Found Poem Favorite | ‘Storytelling’

The fourth in our series of ten "favorites" we've chosen from 650 submissions to our Found Poem Student Challenge.

June 03
(10)

How Do You Feel About Proms?

Student Opinion Question | Tell us your feelings about and experiences with formal school dances like proms.

June 03

A New York Times First: Female Executive Editor

Who are Bill Keller, Jill Abramson and Dean Baquet?

June 03

Test Yourself | History, June 3, 2011

Why were students and others protesting in Beijing, China, in 1989?

June 03

News Quiz | June 3, 2011

See what you know about the news of the day.