Daniel Pipes gave a sober, mixed assessment of Netanyahu's speech. After listing several high points, he notes:
But Netanyahu does not lay down enough conditions for that theoretical moment. All he requires is a formalistic guarantee and recognition, which the years of Israeli-Palestinian diplomacy should have established as inadequate. In addition, the Israeli government should also require, at the least:
A complete overhaul of messages coming from textbooks, classrooms, media, sermons, political rhetoric, and the other areas of public Palestinian discourse, eliminating the anti-Semitism, the anti-Zionism, and the incitement while condemning terrorism and other acts of "resistance" (muqawama).
A protracted era in which Palestinians do not engage in violence against Israelis.
Normal relations in such areas as trade, tourism, sports, and scholarly exchanges.
A good-neighborly foreign policy.
[link]
Jennifer Rubin writes:
Netanyahu provided a robust retort to Obama concerning Zionism and the right of the Jewish people to a state. Obama would have us believe it is out of sympathy for the Jews because of the Holocaust that the world gave Israel its state. This is false and Netanyahu said so.
...One can’t but admit what a vast gulf there is between Obama’s distorted history and Netanyahu’s accurate one, and between Obama’s formulation that Israel’s territorial concessions must precede unconditional recongition and Netanyahu’s diametrically opposite view.
Where do we go from here? Nowhere, it seems. But let’s be honest that we weren’t going anywhere before. The Palestinians have no viable government, have not resolved their internal conflict between the PA and Hamas and still refuse to concede Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state. So the rest is, pardon the expression, commentary.
[link]
Unsurprisingly, Palestinian Authority officials were not pleased. Anything less than "The Jews are leaving the Middle East" would not meet with their approval:
Palestinian Authority officials in Ramallah expressed outrage and shock on Sunday over Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu's call for the establishment of a demilitarized Palestinian state and his demand that the Palestinians recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
The officials said that the speech that Netanyahu delivered at Bar-Ilan University was much worse than they had expected.
They also warned that Netanyahu's policies would trigger a new intifada.
[link]
Egypt's President Hosni Mubarak had a very negative response:
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's demand in a key speech Sunday that Palestinians recognize Israel as the state of the Jewish people "scuttles the chances for peace," Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak said Monday.
"...You won't find anyone to answer that call in Egypt, or in any other place," Mubarak was quoted as telling the troops.
[link]
Recent Comments